Why Remodeling Can Go Over Budget

Residential Construction

Custom Kitchen in Wimberley

Why Remodeling Often Goes Over Budget & Why Some Contractors Avoid Remodeling Projects.

Remodeling a home can be an exciting way to refresh a living space, improve functionality, or increase property value. However, many homeowners are surprised to find that their remodeling projects end up costing far more than originally planned. Not only do budgets get stretched, but some contractors actively avoid remodeling projects altogether. Why is that? In this blog, we’ll explore the reasons behind common budget overruns in remodeling and why contractors sometimes shy away from these types of projects.

1. Unforeseen Structural Issues

One of the most common reasons remodeling projects go over budget is the discovery of hidden structural problems. Older homes, in particular, may have issues like outdated wiring, plumbing problems, or rotting wood hidden behind walls, floors, or ceilings. These issues only come to light once demolition begins, and addressing them can require significant, unanticipated expenditures.

Why Contractors Avoid It: Contractors prefer predictability, and remodeling projects often come with more unknowns compared to new builds. Having to stop work to address these problems can cause delays and require specialized skills, which complicates project management.

Example: Tearing down a bathroom wall might reveal that the plumbing system is out of date and needs a full replacement. This unexpected finding can add thousands to the budget.

2. Scope Creep

Scope creep occurs when the homeowner keeps adding to the original plan. During the project, it’s common for homeowners to decide on additional work—like upgrading countertops, changing floor plans, or adding custom cabinetry. While these decisions may seem small, they can significantly increase both the project timeline and the budget.

Why Contractors Avoid It: Remodeling projects are more prone to scope creep because homeowners are often making design decisions on the fly. This can make managing expectations and costs difficult for contractors. Some contractors prefer the more straightforward, controlled environment of new builds.

Example: A homeowner might initially plan to remodel just the kitchen, but halfway through the project, they decide to redo the adjacent living room as well. This change requires more time, materials, and labor, pushing the project well beyond the initial budget.

3. Inaccurate Estimates and Under Budgeting

Many homeowners don’t have a clear understanding of the costs involved in a remodeling project, leading them to set unrealistic budgets from the start. Sometimes, contractors themselves may underestimate the true cost in order to win the bid, knowing that the project will end up costing more. While this isn’t ideal practice, it happens more frequently than you might think.

Why Contractors Avoid It: Experienced contractors know that remodeling often involves more guesswork than new construction. They may shy away from remodeling projects because they don’t want to risk disappointing clients who may not fully understand the scope and costs involved.

Example: A contractor might give a rough estimate for a kitchen remodel based on a homeowner’s desire for “mid-range finishes.” However, when the homeowner selects high-end materials or adds luxury features like custom cabinetry or advanced appliances, the original budget becomes obsolete.

4. Material Costs and Availability

Material costs can fluctuate due to supply chain issues, changes in demand, or other economic factors. Even if the initial estimate for materials was accurate, price increases during the project can cause costs to spiral out of control. In addition, some specific materials or fixtures might be on backorder, forcing delays and extra shipping fees for alternatives.

Why Contractors Avoid It: The volatility of the material supply chain can create headaches for contractors. They might end up being blamed for delays or higher costs, even though these issues are outside their control. New construction projects typically have more predictable timelines and budgets for materials.

Example: Lumber prices can vary drastically, sometimes doubling within months. If your remodel requires a significant amount of wood, such as for flooring or framing, this price jump could add thousands to your project unexpectedly.

5. Permitting and Code Compliance

Remodeling projects, especially major ones like adding rooms or altering plumbing and electrical systems, often require building permits and must comply with local building codes. Acquiring these permits can be both time-consuming and costly. In some cases, older homes may not be up to code, necessitating additional work to bring the property into compliance.

Why Contractors Avoid It: Navigating permits and code requirements can be a hassle, particularly in remodeling where the existing structure may not meet modern standards. This can lead to significant delays and frustration for both contractors and homeowners.

Example: You might plan to remodel your basement into a livable space, only to find that the ceiling height or the windows don’t meet the local code requirements for habitable rooms. Bringing the space up to code can add unexpected costs and time to the project.

6. Unrealistic Timelines

Many homeowners underestimate the amount of time a remodeling project can take. They may expect work to be completed in just a few weeks, while the reality is that even a simple bathroom remodel can take months. Delays can be caused by material shortages, subcontractor scheduling conflicts, or unexpected problems with the home itself. A longer project timeline inevitably leads to higher labor costs and potentially other budget overruns.

Why Contractors Avoid It: Remodeling projects often require coordinating multiple trades (electricians, plumbers, carpenters), and unforeseen delays are common. Contractors might avoid remodeling projects to escape the logistical headaches that arise from managing so many moving parts on a project with lots of unknowns.

Example: A contractor may plan for a kitchen remodel to take 8 weeks, but delays in countertop delivery or a required plumbing overhaul could easily push the project to 12 weeks, increasing labor costs and causing homeowner frustration.

7. Homeowner Decisions

Homeowners are often presented with many decisions throughout the remodeling process, from choosing fixtures and finishes to approving design changes. When homeowners delay decisions or change their minds mid-project, it can throw off the entire schedule and budget.

Why Contractors Avoid It: Contractors prefer projects with a clear and definitive plan. Remodeling projects can suffer from frequent changes, which frustrates contractors, causes delays, and makes it hard to control the budget.

Example: If a homeowner decides halfway through a bathroom remodel that they want a different tile, the contractor will need to pause, reorder materials, and rework the schedule—adding time and labor costs to the project.

Conclusion

Remodeling projects are prone to budget overruns due to the many variables and unforeseen issues that can arise once work begins. Unforeseen structural problems, scope creep, material price fluctuations, and code compliance challenges all contribute to the unpredictability of remodeling. For contractors, the uncertainty, potential for delays, and constant need for client approval can make remodeling a less appealing job compared to new construction, where projects are typically more straightforward.

If you’re planning a remodeling project, the key to keeping your budget under control is thorough planning, clear communication with your contractor, and preparing for the unexpected. Choose a contractor with remodeling experience, make decisions early, and try to stick to your original plan as much as possible to avoid the common pitfalls that lead to budget blowouts.

If have ideas and you’re not sure what to expect for your budget or remodeling project, you can hire a consultant or start the estimation process. Just be sure to have an open mind and some wriggle room.

To top